Testing the effect of behavioural interventions on agri-environment scheme optio
Awarded 28 Oct 2026
About
Testing the effect of behavioural interventions on agri-environment scheme option selection This project follows a series of Choice Architecture Tests (CATs) that have been commissioned by Defra's Farming Directorate Behavioural Science and Analytics team.
These CATs have tested various interventions in a hypothetical agri-environment scheme application environment to understand their effect on option selection.
Key findings include: • CAT 1 : tested the effect of defaults (pre-selected actions) on a hypothetical Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) application.
Results showed a statistically significant increase in the environmental quality of the agreement generated through defaults compared to the current SFI application design.
• CAT 2 : tested the effect of defaults and guided selection on a hypothetical Countryside Stewardship (CS) mid-tier application.
Results for CAT 2 also showed defaults being effective.
Compared to the current CS mid-tier design & some aspects of guided selection tested during the experiment, defaults led to more spatially targeted actions being chosen (the primary outcome of the experiment) by farmers, which might indicate higher quality environmental agreements.
• CAT 3 : tested the effect of geospatial functionality (presenting guidance on spatial priorities visually) and offering a default totaliser (that shows the potential financial reward for choosing options) on a hypothetical SFI application.
The study found no evidence that the tool changed the mean number of spatial priorities per action selected.
The tool significantly reduced the total number of actions selected.
• CAT 4 : used qualitative methods to test the effect of offering defaults with farmers who find it difficult to access and use digital tools and services, (i.e.
those with low 'digital literacy'), to assess whether findings from CAT 1 & CAT 2 are consistent for these farmers.
The major barriers to using digital technology were confidence, time and motivation, though barriers to applying for ELM schemes independently were not primarily related to digital skills.
Defaults were not viewed positively but highlighting and the review page were.
• CAT 5 : tested the effect of "Object Oriented" (OO) framing, which categorises information by tangible, real-life objects aligned with farmers' mental models, on finding and understanding of regulatory information.
Overall, OO framing did not significantly improve navigation and understanding.
Similar open tenders12
GovMarket
We do the hard work.
You win the work.
We find the tenders, read the documents and track who wins, so your time goes on bids you can win.





